Finding the perfect toilet paper can be a challenging task, balancing cost-effectiveness with quality. Cheap rolls may initially seem like a bargain, but they often end up feeling rough and uncomfortable, making your bathroom experience far from pleasant. On the other hand, splurging on expensive toilet paper doesn’t always guarantee a superior product that meets your needs.
Apart from comfort, it’s crucial to consider the flushability of toilet paper. Opting for toilet paper that dissolves easily in water is essential to prevent potential plumbing issues, such as clogs or septic problems. No one wants to deal with a toilet backup caused by unsuitable toilet paper.
The market offers a wide range of toilet paper choices, each claiming to have unique features that cater to different preferences. From ultra-plush and luxurious options to quick-dissolving and septic-safe rolls, consumers have an array of products to choose from.
Berkley Jensen Ultra Soft Bath Tissue:
- Price and Availability: $20 at BJ’s
- Pros:
- Aced absorbency tests
- High scores for softness
- Dissolves quickly
- Cons:
- Not as strong as other brands when wet
- Overview: BJ’s toilet paper is an excellent value, acing absorbency tests and dissolving quickly. It received high scores for softness and was defect-free.
Great Value Ultra Soft Toilet Paper:
- Price and Availability: $13 at Walmart
- Pros:
- Top marks for softness
- Dissolves quickly
- High ranking for thickness
- Cons:
- Weaker when wet
- Overview: Despite its low price, this Walmart brand toilet paper offers good softness and quick dissolution. It performs well in strength tests but may be weaker when wet.
Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper:
- Prices and Availability: $40 at Amazon, $30 at Walmart
- Pros:
- Top ratings for softness by testers and lab equipment
- Thick and plush feel
- High strength scores
- Cons:
- Doesn’t dissolve easily
- Overview: Charmin stands out for its softness and strength, but it may not be suitable for septic systems due to its slower dissolution.
Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare Toilet Paper:
- Price and Availability: $52 at Amazon
- Pros:
- No pilling or layer separation
- High absorbency scores
- Rippled texture to help clean
- Cons:
- Slower to dissolve
- Overview: Cottonelle offers strength and absorbency, but it dissolves relatively slowly. Its rippled texture ensures effective cleaning.
Scott Small Core High Capacity Bath Tissue:
- Price and Availability: $84 at Amazon
- Pros:
- More than double the sheets per roll than others
- Brand’s toilet paper excelled in dissolvability tests
- Cons:
- May not fit on certain toilet paper holders
- Overview: Scott’s high capacity toilet paper is suitable for bulk buyers, but the small core design may not fit all holders.
Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper:
- Price and Availability: $29 at Amazon
- Pros:
- Strong when wet
- High scores for absorbency
- Super thick and soft
- Cons:
- Doesn’t break down easily
- Overview: This three-ply toilet paper offers superior strength and softness, but it may not dissolve easily.
Seventh Generation 100% Recycled Bath Tissue:
- Price and Availability: $55 at Amazon
- Pros:
- Dissolved quickly in our tests
- Fairly soft and absorbent
- Cons:
- Not as strong as other options
- Overview: A sustainable option, Seventh Generation’s toilet paper offers quick dissolvability and environmental friendliness.
Who Gives a Crap Bamboo Toilet Paper:
- Price and Availability: $44 at Who Gives a Crap
- Pros:
- Subscription service available
- Softer than some other sustainable TPs we’ve tried
- Cons:
- Thinner than other options
- Overview: Made from bamboo, this three-ply toilet paper is soft and dissolves easily, making it a sustainable choice with a subscription option.
